|
Title: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Sandiwich11 on September 12, 2010, 05:28:46 pm I have to admit that my list does tend to change a little bit depending on what I have watched recently :P But here is how they stand atm:
River Song Rory Williams Wilf Mott Captain Jack Mickey Smith Donna Noble Rose Tyler Martha Jones Amy Pond Sarah Jane Smith Jackson Lake Astrid Peth Lady Christina de Souza If I was counting The Brig he would totally pwn them all thou ;D Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: DAK on September 13, 2010, 03:51:30 pm Here's mine, I think. LOL It gets kind of arbitrary after the top half dozen or so:
River Song Donna Noble Captain Jack Rory Williams Amy Pond Wilf Mott Rose Tyler Martha Jones Mickey Smith Sarah Jane Smith Jackson Lake Astrid Peth Lady Christina de Souza What about Jackie - would you consider her a companion? Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Sandiwich11 on September 13, 2010, 09:34:18 pm Hmm, I suppose she is, she would be after Lady Christina for me thou :(
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Iceman on September 13, 2010, 09:36:49 pm Captain Jack
Rose Tyler Martha Jones River Song Rory Williams Mickey Smith Amy Pond Wilf Mott Sarah Jane Smith Donna Noble Lady Christina de Souza Jackson Lake Astrid Peth Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: The Doc on September 13, 2010, 09:51:36 pm Donna Noble
Martha Jones River Song Wilfred Mott Rory Williams Astrid Peth Rose Tyler Rosita Amy Pond Lady Christina Adelaide Brooke Mickey Smith Jackson Lake Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Iceman on September 13, 2010, 09:56:00 pm Donna Noble Martha Jones River Song Wilfred Mott Rory Williams Astrid Peth Rose Tyler Rosita Amy Pond Lady Christina Adelaide Brooke Mickey Smith Jackson Lake Jack doesn't count? :o Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: sleekituk on September 13, 2010, 10:01:18 pm Donna Noble
Captain Jack Martha Jones Wilfred Mott Sarah Jane Smith Rose Tyler Rory Williams Mickey Smith Rosita Adelaide Brooke Jackson Lake Amy Pond Astrid Peth Lady Christina River Song Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: The Doc on September 13, 2010, 10:08:00 pm I forgot about Jack. Stick him in after Astrid.
Love him, but not so much in DW as TW Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Iceman on September 13, 2010, 10:09:32 pm All the staff seems to hate Mickey. Perhaps I should change my avatar.
I don't like him in season 1, but I do like epic badass bearded Mickey :P Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: The Doc on September 13, 2010, 10:11:48 pm I think Mickey is a bit of a berk to be honest. Beard or no
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Iceman on September 13, 2010, 10:15:03 pm What's the American equivalent of "Berk"?
No idea what that means :P Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: The Doc on September 13, 2010, 10:18:46 pm Erm, pillock? ****? Moron etc
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Iceman on September 13, 2010, 10:21:20 pm Erm, pillock? ****? Moron etc Oh. Right. Thanks. Lol Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: sleekituk on September 13, 2010, 10:35:35 pm I don't hate Mickey! I just like Rory a little more! I really enjoyed his character development tbh ;D
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Iceman on September 13, 2010, 10:38:51 pm I don't hate Mickey! I just like Rory a little more! I really enjoyed his character development tbh ;D Yeah. He was bad in season 1.But I gather you don't like Mickey and Martha together right? (I'm their biggest fan, so I was just curious) Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: sleekituk on September 13, 2010, 10:45:27 pm It just came out of nowhere a bit, that's all. I loved Martha and Tom, but I'm glad they both got a happy ending, if that makes sense?
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Iceman on September 13, 2010, 10:50:00 pm Oh ok. Yep it does. ;D
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Doomsday on September 14, 2010, 08:36:29 pm Rose Tyler
Donna Noble River Song Lady Christina Martha Jones Wilfred Mott Adelaide Brooke Astrid Peth Rosita Amy Pond Mickey Smith Jackson Lake Rory Williams Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: The Doc on September 14, 2010, 09:28:47 pm Didnt expect to see Rory so low down on anyones list :o
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: GreenLemons on September 14, 2010, 09:31:15 pm Donna
Wilf Rory Jack Amy Martha :D Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: TheReverendMrMagister on September 15, 2010, 08:31:04 pm ;D Rory 10/10
:D Mickey 8/10 :) Amy 6/10 :) Donna 6/10 :( Martha 5/10 ::) Jack 3/10 :-[ Rose 0/10 Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Doomsday on September 18, 2010, 05:59:28 pm Didnt expect to see Rory so low down on anyones list :o I can't stand Rory. Like really dislike the guy. And especially when he is around Amy. I really dislike the whole Rory and Amy thing travelling together with the Doctor. It just doesn't sit well with me. Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Vampyros Adric on September 22, 2010, 12:35:04 pm Donna
Wilf Rose Jack River Rory Martha Jack Jackson/Lady Christina/Astrid/Adelaide (Liked them v. much but not companion for long enough - wish they had been) Mickey Pond Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: GreenLemons on September 22, 2010, 01:30:02 pm You dont like pond? :(
BUT yaaay Donna :D Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Vampyros Adric on September 22, 2010, 07:27:14 pm You dont like pond? :( BUT yaaay Donna :D It's weird isn't it? But I really don't like Pond - perhaps she's one like Mel from Classic Who that will grow on me in time to come! Gotta lotta love for the DoctorDonna though :) Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: GreenLemons on September 22, 2010, 07:35:39 pm Hehe, okay :P She's not the best companion - but I think she's pretty darn good. I'd be better though! :D
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: The Doc on September 22, 2010, 07:36:54 pm Donna is just the best. I think if anyone every takes over her in terms of pure brilliance, I shall turn into the Racnoss and die. Thats how unlikely I see it :P
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: GreenLemons on September 22, 2010, 07:38:12 pm It'd be true if I was the companion :D
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Vampyros Adric on September 22, 2010, 08:01:13 pm I've got to be honest, I would have put Wilf above Donna if he'd had a whole season with the Doctor. But Donna played it so pitch perfect and I always thought Wilf was there to help progress the Donna story. Even as a companion in EOT, I thought Wilf was there to remind us that Donna couldn't be there (if that makes sense). Those two were way out in front for me
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: GreenLemons on September 22, 2010, 08:10:35 pm Ohh, I loved Wilf so much! He made me so happy! When he cried, I cried! <3
Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: 2cajuman2 on September 23, 2010, 02:06:54 am Well, this isn't easy, but I decided to have a go..... Jack was the only easy one.... And I have segmented them in to groups, I segmented after ordering but they fitted... ::)
Captain Jack River Song Rose Tyler Rory Williams Amy Pond Sarah Jane Smith K-9 Mickey Smith (of S1 and 2) Wilf Mott Donna Noble Mickey Smith (of S4) Martha Jones The companions who aren't really real companions: Sally Sparrow Adam Adelaide Lady Christina de Souza Jackson Lake Astrid Peth And No, Mickey and Martha should not have happened. The End. Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: 2cajuman2 on September 23, 2010, 02:09:47 am Jack River Rory Martha Jack Which Jack warrants the higher ranking? Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Green_Lemons on February 25, 2012, 08:35:42 pm Donna Wilf Rory Jack Amy Martha :D Awwww my old account! Yeah that's still pretty accurate :3 Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Roranicus on February 25, 2012, 09:19:41 pm I love it when old threads get dug up :D
Ok, here goes! Rory Donna Martha River Wilf Rose Amy Adelaide Astrid Jack Christina Mickey Jackson Think I got them all Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Joshua on March 03, 2012, 11:21:02 am Donna Noble
Rose Tyler River Song Amy Pond Rory Williams Captain Jack Martha Jones Mickey Smith I'm not including any one off companions, as they don't really count IMO and would probably be lower than these guys based on numbers alone. Rory appears in the middle not because I like him, but because I dislike the others. Title: Re: [New Series] Rank the Companions Post by: Scott on March 03, 2012, 01:59:11 pm Martha Donna River Rose Amy Rory Jack Mickey |