Was this voted by the fans or just compiled by the magazine based on their own opinions?
By the fans. Readers of the magazine were asked to give each story they had seen a mark out of 10. They then took the average score for every story (which they then turned into a percentage for some reason) and ranked the stories accordingly.
Oh right. Seems like a random way of doing things but I suppose it was the fairest way. I still dont agree with many placings though