Message #20688

[BlueRose]

I would go on with the reasons why I dislike River and don't see her as a viable character, but that belongs in the thread established for that.

In any event, Rose started out as a strong character in her own right in S1. From there on end, not so much. I think RTD tried too hard with the romance plotline there and it fell flat for her character.

I have pretty good reasons for feeling the way I do as a whole, and I'm not liking where this thread is heading in terms of its overall tone. We're going to have to remember that not every fan feels the same way about characters and writers, and that isn't a reflection on them, it's merely a different in opinion and perspective.